Cay Syrah

· Villa



Cay Syrah Villa – 6 bed / 5.5 bath handicap accessible villa in greater Cruz Bay

Welcome to Cay Syrah! A newly constructed, 6-bedroom villa with 5,000 square feet of air conditioned indoor space on three floors, Cay Syrah also has 1,200 square feet of covered outdoor space, 800 square feet of sunny pool deck with outdoor kitchen, and a surprise 800 square foot rooftop stargazing deck. Located on the west side of St John, Cay Syrah is a short 3-minute drive to Cruz Bay, and boasts amazing views of Pillsbury Sound and sunsets over St Thomas.

Cay Syrah is perfect for a multi-generational vacation as it is a handicap accessible house with a grand, and gracious ramp connecting the top two levels. The Villa was designed to accommodate the mobility challenged and features accessible bathrooms with easy entry no-curb showers that also have seats, grab bars, and both a fixed head and hand-held shower. Function and beauty coexist in this villa! While not fully ADA compliant, very few villas (if any) on St. John can compare with Cay Syrah’s accessibility. Please ask about the equipment we have available should you need them while renting.

Handicap accessible features include:
Ramp for access between top two floors
All doors 36” minimum wide
No curb showers with seats, both fixed and handheld shower heads
Wheelchair on site for use as needed

Entry to the house is off a wide driveway with ample space to park 4 cars and a turnaround spot for easy maneuvering. Two additional cars can park on the street directly in front of the house. The site has been carefully and thoughtfully landscaped and includes several fruit trees, all of which bear eatable treasures at various times of the year including bananas, mangoes, papayas, limes, and starfruit. Make sure to ask your greeter what is in season and they will show you how to pick and enjoy those fruits.

The covered front porch and magnificent top-floor main entrance door is like no other on island. The beautiful stained-glass door was once the entry to a gallery on Rodeo Drive in Beverly Hills, CA. The owners of Cay Syrah believe what you see through the door now far surpasses what it once protected.

The air-conditioned top level of Cay Syrah includes an open floor plan with great room, dining room and chef’s kitchen. A full 12-foot wide pocketing sliding door system brings the indoor and outdoor living together with separate comfortable seating and dining areas on the covered outdoor deck.

The chef’s kitchen features custom mahogany cabinets, granite counter tops, a separate full-sized refrigerator and full-sized freezer, a double oven and 5 burner gas cook-top, and 2 full-sized dishwashers. The kitchen island is topped with a beautiful onyx slab. The owners have visited St John at least annually for over 20 years now enjoy hosting dinner parties for their friends. This house is designed for just such fun and can also accommodate a small wedding or other such party if prior approval has been granted.

The dining room is a favorite for many who have visited Cay Syrah. The room is anchored by a beautiful, burled maple table with seating for 12, and includes a mix of chairs, both modern and antique. An antique English mahogany secretary circa 1850, an American marbled top oak buffet circa 1900, and a singer sewing machine-based spool cabinet (circa 1890) all furnish the room. Decorative stained-glass hangs in all the windows.

The upstairs master has a king bed, large underbed safe, and ensuite bathroom with a large, no-curb shower and double sink vanity. The bathroom is wheelchair accessible and includes several well positioned grab bars and a full seat in the shower.

A uniquely designed interior stairway, covered exterior stairs from the deck, and a graciously sloped exterior ramp all lead to the mid-level which has three more ensuite bedrooms, pool, outdoor kitchen/cafe, and laundry room. Two of these bedrooms are set up with king-sized beds with the third set up with two twins which can be converted to a king as needed. Each bathroom has a no-curb shower, again for ease of entry should additional guests require handicap accessibility. The outdoor kitchen has an outdoor television for viewing – even while in the saltwater pool. The pool also has gates installed at critical entry points so that the pool can be made off limits for younger guests.

The lower level of the house, the garden apartment, is not handicap accessible. Access to this level is by exterior stairs either from the driveway or the pool deck. The garden level apartment has two bedrooms, a great room, full kitchen, and one bathroom. One bedroom is setup with a king-sized bed and the other, smaller bedroom, has twin bunk beds – great for children. This level also boasts a tiki hut bar with cover seating and a lawn for yard games.


High Season Rates

2020 / 2021
1-8 Guests = $10,500/wk

2020 / 2021 Thanksgiving
1-8 Guests = $9,500/wk

2020 / 2021 Holiday
1-8 Guests = $13,500/wk

*Additional $375/pp/per wk – max 12 guests

Off Season Rates

2020 / 2021 
1-8 Guests = $6,500/wk

*Additional $375/pp/per wk – max 12 guests




Serendip Rd, Cruz Bay, St John 00830, USVI


Please contact us to confirm availability, ask a question or to make a reservation.

*All rates are subject to change and do not include 12.5% hotel tax.

Deposit: 50% deposit at time of reservation. Balance due 60 days prior to arrival.
Damage deposit: $1,500 refundable deposit or CSA damage insurance
Payment method: We accept checks or MasterCard or Visa with a 3% convenience fee

Maximum of 40 guests
$5,000 event fee plus additional damage deposit
Prior Approval Required

Ask? - Quote - Book

Message has been sent successfully.
Page Viewed: 01/2021: 409 / 989 Lifetime


Sarah & Neil Pennywitt

(805) 279-0984
(805) 279-0984

Cay Syrah is perfect for a multi-generational vacation as it is a handicap accessible house with a grand, and gracious ramp connecting the top two levels. The Villa was designed to accommodate the mobility challenged and features accessible bathrooms with..